2007/Mar/07

What is the role of the film critic in the digital age? To some it's the same as it's always been; others see criticism as the 'vinyl to the bloggers' iPod'. What do you think?

Last night's Guardian Film Forum at Bafta in London took as its subject "the role of the film critic in the digital age". Against a backdrop of internet enthusiasm for all things cinematic (which goes back practically to the inception of the world wide web) and old media's equally enthusiastic embrace of blogging (what you're reading now would not exist otherwise) - we ask the question: where does that leave the film critic?

Panellist Sam Nichols, head of distribution for UK indie outfit Momentum was very clear on the positive effect of film blogging on her work. "It is a community we're embracing," she said, "We're not discouraging it at all." Nichols explained that she increasingly works with "elements" of a particular film - clips, trailers, video diaries - that will feed the buzz and get bloggers excited before the finished film is delivered.

The Guardian's film critic Peter Bradshaw, the next panellist along, welcomed the rise of the blogger. "I envy the blogger's freedom," he says. But in terms of what he writes, he says, it's not changed the pressure. "You have to fight your corner. It's the same as it's always been."

Nick James, editor of Sight and Sound, took the intellectual high ground, pointing out the difference between "reviewing" and "criticism" - the former being a consumer service, and the latter a lengthy analysis of a film - and saying that he saw no reason to despair for the future of criticism: he wanted Sight and Sound, he said, "to be the vinyl to the bloggers' iPod".

Hannah McGill, former critic of the Herald and now director of the Edinburgh film festival, was blunter in her approach to the blogging critic: "It's like talking to people you meet in a bar: some of them are great, others are just shouters."

Once discussion was opened up to the floor, things got a tad more heated. Bradshaw opined that the critical establishment was suffering what he termed "karmic justice ... the newspapers were a one-party state for so long but the web has brought that to an end. Critics have got to come to terms with that."

The bloggers' point of view was put forward by Tom and Marek from the nine-month old Solace in Cinema. Tom explained they were trying to build a community with their blog. "We read things, and post them - my feeling is, let's start talking about it." Merrick was a bit unnerved at what he saw as hostility from the mainstream media; it was about "democratising the process" he said, a theme taken up by Mike from The Londonist. "It's all about citizen journalism," he said. "If no one read us, we'd probably just shut up."

The strongest counter to blogging's ethos of self-empowerment came from David Gritten, a film critic from the Daily Telegraph. He cited the example of proto-blogger Harry Knowles and the embarrassing collapse of credibility his Aint It Cool website suffered: "As soon as the studios stopped excluding them, they were immediately in the studio's pocket." He suggested that the fact the film industry didn't like the mainstream media was itself a virtue: "We are the only part of the process they can't control."

This was a point that no one on the blogging side could refute convincingly. As if to back it up, the last word came from Steve Hunt, who works for the British arm of the Hollywood studio Paramount. "Blogging is, for us, just another carriage, a way to get through to our audience."

http://blogs.guardian.co.uk/film/2007/03/whither_the_film_critic_in_the.html

Comment

Comment:

Tweet


At present, college students have an opportunity not to pay big attention at creating research essays. They can buy a research paper and feel free.
#732 by write my papers (193.105.210.41) At 2011-08-11 22:08,
You know that you can to see the well done theme about written essay and even about this good topic in the professional essay writing service. Thence, you have a chance to try out that.
#731 by essay writing (193.105.210.41) At 2011-08-11 19:47,
It is important to train your essays writing skills. But, time makes students slave. There're situations when we do not have enough time even for easy essays writing. Fortunately, we can use a chance to get information how to write an essay and get free time.
#730 by I want to buy an essays (193.105.210.41) At 2011-08-11 07:59,
7oemYS <a href="http://sqtttnqvhwek.com/">sqtttnqvhwek</a>, [url=http://fyvesgokfemv.com/]fyvesgokfemv[/url], [link=http://tytgeyuobajo.com/]tytgeyuobajo[/link], http://jaiaojyneqny.com/
#729 by luuOuRWNP (79.142.67.91) At 2010-10-18 17:05,
nPV1cF <a href="http://nyevuuzuyrtq.com/">nyevuuzuyrtq</a>, [url=http://sxcqjihhsdix.com/]sxcqjihhsdix[/url], [link=http://thicywddusxu.com/]thicywddusxu[/link], http://ikflkwqjiocu.com/
#728 by HVDBvTTlX (79.142.67.83) At 2010-10-12 23:31,
5zw2j4 <a href="http://adsnzizfwadu.com/">adsnzizfwadu</a>, [url=http://asjuifnylljc.com/]asjuifnylljc[/url], [link=http://xpmjdyrqritl.com/]xpmjdyrqritl[/link], http://jxyecqcnykif.com/
#727 by tJptiZsokLEqenElFhk (91.212.226.56) At 2010-09-27 19:26,
cU5ZqU <a href="http://jhsoqavixpkd.com/">jhsoqavixpkd</a>, [url=http://defzkuyeekin.com/]defzkuyeekin[/url], [link=http://ujrirahzsghj.com/]ujrirahzsghj[/link], http://vdjemfzllcio.com/
#726 by SPblpTZDumjwvH (213.5.64.21) At 2010-08-14 03:07,
b7VnYy <a href="http://avzhsfwzqbvk.com/">avzhsfwzqbvk</a>, [url=http://crpvoswxncii.com/]crpvoswxncii[/url], [link=http://tfelxpuchpdl.com/]tfelxpuchpdl[/link], http://goqrzpekjzto.com/
#725 by nNxEPtQFC (213.5.64.21) At 2010-07-30 07:27,
comment4, ñâèíã òóëà çíàêîìñòâî, ëåñáè çíàêîìñòâà âî âëàäèìèðå, çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ ñåêñà â êóñòàíàå,
#724 by Anxmlgxg (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 20:26,
comment3, çíàêîìñòâà æåíùèíû ìîãèëåâ áåëàðóññèÿ, èíòèì çíàêîìñòâà òàâäà, áðàòñê çíàêîìñòâà ñåêñ ïðîñòèòóòêà, çíàêîìñòâà ãîðîä íîãèíñê 50 ëåò,
#723 by Hutwbjrp (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 20:10,
comment6, óêðàèíà íèêîëàåâ ïðîñòèòóòêè ñåêñ çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâî ñî ñïîíñîðîì, çíàêîìñòâà ìèðíûé àðõàíã, èíòèì çíàêîìñòâà îðåíáóðãñêàÿ îáëàñòü,
#722 by Uruywwvf (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 19:59,
comment3, çíàêîìñòâà â íàõàáèíî, çíàêîìñòâà ñ äåâóøêàìè äî 25 ëåò, çíàêîìñòâà â ãîðîäå ïðîêîïüåâñêå,
#721 by Wcenmeqo (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 19:25,
comment2, çíàêîìñòâà ã.óëüÿíîâñê, òðàíñâåñòèò èùåò çíàêîìñòâà â ÿðîñëàâëå, ñåêñ çíàêîìñòâà áåëàðóñü äîñêà,
#720 by Regxpdih (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 19:18,
comment1, íàéòè â çíàêîìñòâàõ äåâóøêó ïî èìåíè ýëþøà, çíàêîìñòâà â êåñîâå ãîðå, àìóðñêàÿ îáë çíàêîìñòâî ñåêñ, çíàêîìñòâà èíòèìíî å óñëóãè àäðåñà òåë ã. âîëíîâàõà äîíåöêîé îáëàñòè,
#719 by Fjsdhbal (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 19:07,
comment4, èíòèìñèòè ðó ñàéò, çíàêîìñòâà â ðîññèå, âèðòóàëüíîå çíàêîìñòâî ñåêñ è ëþáîâü, çíàêîìñòâà àáèíñê,
#718 by Epakvkeq (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:56,
comment3, èíòèì çíàêîìñòâà òóò, áîðèñîâñêèå çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà òþìåíå,
#717 by Zpmitpkf (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:51,
comment3, çíàêîìñòâà èíòèì êðåìåí÷óã, àðàëüíûé çíàêîìñòâà àñòðàõàíü, çíàêîìñòâà ñî çíàìåíèòîñòÿìè ðîññèÿ,
#716 by Uefxkmln (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:45,
comment5, çíàêîìñòâà ñî ñìàéëèêàìè, õî÷ó ïîçíàêîìèòüñÿ ñ èçðàèëüòÿíèíîì, çíàêîìñòâî ãîðîä ÷åõîâ äåâóøêè, çíàêîìñòâî äåâ÷îíêàìè â òþìåíè,
#715 by Hieziifw (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:39,
comment1, òðàíñåêñóàëû çíàêîìñòâà â õàáàðîâñêå, çíàêîìñòâà ñ òóíèñöàìè, çíàêîìñòâà â ãîðîäå óðþïèíñê, ñåêñ çíàêîìñòâà â êóéáûøåâ íñî,
#714 by Iumvqame (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:33,
comment2, çíàêîìñòâî àãèíñêîå, ñåêñ çíàêîìñòâà ðàäóæíûé õìàî, ñàéòû äëÿ ðåàëüíîãî -çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà â óêðàèíå äëÿ îáùåíèÿ,
#713 by Zsuwcenv (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:28,
comment6, çíàêîìñòâà òîëñòûå áàáû, òðàíñâåñòèòû ñ ïåòåðáóðã èíòèì, çíàêîìñòâà â ñàðàòîâå 24 open, çíàêîìñòâà ëîâ ïëàíåòà,
#712 by Hmllyhbh (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:21,
comment6, çíàêîìñòâà áåëûé ðó÷åé, çíàêîìñòâî â ñ íîâîé óñìàíè, çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ ñåêñà ãîðîä çåÿ,
#711 by Obdiucnf (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:10,
comment3, çíàêîìñòâà îõà ñàõàëèíñêîé îáëàñòè, çíàêîìñòâî ñ äåâóøêàìè â ñåâàñòîïîëå, çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ îíàíèñòîâ â ðîñòîâå, ñåêñ çíàêîìñòâà ìèàññ,
#710 by Znevrwmp (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 18:05,
comment3, ñàé þæíî êóðèëüñêà çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà è âñòðå÷è ïåðìü, çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ ñåêñà àëàïàåâñê, çíàêîìñòâà èçâðàùåíèÿ õàêàñèÿ,
#709 by Oencidin (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:58,
comment5, òîëüêî ñåðåçíûå çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà ñåâàñòîïîëüñêàÿ, ñåêñ çíàêîìñòâà â ãîðîäå àñòðàõàíü,
#708 by Hdmhwovj (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:54,
comment1, çíàêîìñòâà ýëÿ âëàäèâîñòîê, çíàêîìñòâà ñ ðóññêèìè æèâóùèìè çàãðàíèöåé, çíàêîìñòâà ìóæ÷èíû çà 40,
#707 by Ncbxmpwe (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:47,
comment2, èíòèì çà äåíüãè ïåòåðáóðã, óêðàèíà îäåññà ãîñïîæà çíàêîìñòâà, èùó æåíùèíó äëÿ èíòèì âñòðå÷,
#706 by Lgthjxop (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:42,
comment2, èíòèì çàêîìñòâà êðàñíîäàð, áè çíàêîìñòâà óêðàèíà, èíòèì çíàêîìñòâà áåíäåðû, çíàêîìñòâà ìàìáà êóîãàí,
#705 by Genlqghz (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:31,
comment1, çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ ñýêñà í.íîâãîðä, çíàêîìñòâà èç êîëîíèé, èíòèì ïàâëîâî íèæåãîðîäñêîé, çíàêîìñòâà â êîñòîìå,
#704 by Qonjvwgz (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:25,
comment4, èíòèì çíàêîìñòâà â ðîññîøè, çíàêîìñòâî äíåïðîäåðæèíñê, èíòèì çíàêîìñòâà êóðòàìûø,
#703 by Xpujfjyc (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:19,
comment3, çíàêîìñòâà ñ äåâóøêàìè íà wap, òðàíñâåñòèòû ïåíçû çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà êèðîâîãðàäà, çíàêîìñòâî äëÿ âñòðå÷,
#702 by Cfvlaryy (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:13,
comment5, çíàêîìñòâà ãðóïîâîå áàðíàóë, õî÷ó ïîçíàêîìèòüñÿ êèåâà, êàçàõ óðàëüñê çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâî â ãîðîäå âîëüñêå,
#701 by Jvzkcdhv (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 17:01,
comment3, èíòèìíûå çíàêîìñòâà â ìàõà÷êàëå, çíàêîìñòâà â ã îìñêå, âèðòóàëüíûå çíàêîìñòâà â ÷åðêåññêå,
#700 by Ezdpotrr (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 16:34,
comment6, çíàêîìñòâî ñ àìåðèêàíêàìè, èíòèì çíàîêìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà â íüþéîðêå,
#699 by Hfrhculk (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 16:27,
comment2, çíàêîìñòâà - ëó÷øèé ñàéò çíàêîìñòâ, çíàêîìñòâà â èòàëè èñïàíèÿ, ãîëóáûå ïàðíè çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ ñîâìåñòíîãî ïóòåøåñòâèÿ,
#698 by Svnfqnkr (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 16:11,
comment2, çíàêîìñòâà ðóáë¸âêà, áåëàðóñü çíàêîìñòâà äåâóøêè, çíàêîìñòâà èç ñëàâÿíñêà íà êóáàíè, çíàêîìñòâà â åññåíòóêàõ,
#697 by Urxzvurm (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 16:04,
comment4, çíàêîìñòâà ñ äåâóøêîé äëÿ ìèíüåòà, ñåêñ çíàêîìñòâà â èðëàíäèè, çíàêîìñòâî ñåêñ ñ èíîñòðàíêàìè,
#696 by Oeacscwm (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 16:00,
comment3, äåâóøêó èíòèì ñìîëåíñê, âåëèêèé íîâãîðîä èíòèì óñëóãè, çíàêîìñòâà êèëüìåçü,
#695 by Adxmhobl (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 15:53,
comment5, ëåñáè çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ ðåàëüíûõ âñòðå÷ ñåãîäíÿ, çíàêîìñòâà íà ìàìáà ðó, çíàêîìñòâà äåâóøêè íîðìàëüíûå,
#694 by Sxeiriud (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 15:49,
comment4, çíàêîìñòâà ìàãíèòîãîðñê ìóæ÷èíû, çíàêîìñòâà ðåãóëÿðíûé ñåêñ, óðàë çíàêîìñòâà ÷åëÿáèíñê,
#693 by Szycssky (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 15:26,
comment5, çíàêîìñòâà äåâóøêè ñîñíîãîðñê, îäíîîêëàññíèêè çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà àâñòðàëèÿ ñ èíîñòðàíöàìè,
#692 by Leanubbl (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 15:14,
comment6, çíàêîìñòâà òîëüêî ðàäè à â íîâîñèáèðñêå, ñóìû èíòèì äåíüãè, ñàéò çíàêîìñòâà ìèðíûé àðõàíãåëüñêîé îáëàñòè, çíàêîìñòâà ëó÷øå íåò,
#691 by Dbqrzgxp (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:57,
comment1, çíàêîìñòâà àðõèâ ñàíêò ïåòåðáóðã, êàíàäà çíàêîìñòâà ðóññêèå, çíàêîìñòâàâîðîíåæ,
#690 by Umgxunnu (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:45,
comment3, îìñêèå èíòèì çíàêîìñòâà, êàçàõñòàí çíàêîìñòâî êûçûëîðäà, êðàñíûé êóò çíàêîìñòâà,
#689 by Qanzkqjy (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:41,
comment4, çíàêîìñòâà óêðàèíöåâà îëüãà, èòàëüÿíñêèå çíàêîìñòâà, ãäå ìîæíî ïîçíàêîìèòüñÿ ñ ñîëäàòîì,
#688 by Mkmbxsvg (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:29,
comment3, âñå çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ èçâðàøåííîãî ñåêñà, çíàêîìñòâà â çàïîëÿðíîì ìóðìàíñêîé îáëàñòè, çíàêîìñòâà ëåñáè êðàñíîÿðñê äîñêà,
#687 by Jnddiosi (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:23,
comment5, òþìåíñêàÿ îáëàñòü ñóðãóò ïàðíè çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà â ñèñòåìå mamba, çíàêîìñòâà àêèìîâêà,
#686 by Evqjtfmh (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:18,
comment1, äåâóøêà èùåò ïàðíÿ äëÿ èíòèìà, èíòèì ãåëü äëÿ ìóæ÷èí, ìîñêâè÷êà õî÷åò ïîçíàêîìèòüñÿ ñ êàâêàçöåì, ÷àñòíûå ýðîòè÷åñêèå çíàêîìñòâà íèæíåãî òàãèëà,
#685 by Gwkbshxs (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:11,
comment2, ñîñòîÿòåëüíûå ìóæ÷èíû çíàêîìñòâî, èíòèì ñåêñ ïðîñòèòóòêè áåëãîðîäà, îäíîêëàññíèêè çíàêîìñòâî, êàâêàç ñàéò çíàêîìñòâà ÷å÷íÿ,
#684 by Yosjuirh (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 14:06,
comment6, çíàêîìñòâà äëÿ ñýêñà ìèíñê, ïåðåïèñêà ñ àìåðèêàíöàìè çíàêîìñòâà, çíàêîìñòâà â í ÷åëíû ðò, çíàêîìñòâà ñåâåðî çàïàä êàëèíèíãðàä,
#683 by Srfscigk (93.174.93.154) At 2010-07-09 13:55,